Did Rancid leave and come back, or were they never gone? It’s hard to say. What is easy to say is that the band sounds older, and I don’t mean experienced. I mean tired. The songs are fine, but they don’t have the punch that their older efforts had. In other cases, it’s the same old song with new titles. “Last One to Die” has the same melody as “Salvation.” It’s no surprise that it’s the single.
A few gems do emerge, though. “Disconnected” seems to have drawn on the band’s more energetic days. And “Civilian Ways” is fun, even if it doesn’t sound like them. Maybe they see Green Day do ballads for money and want to do the same thing. Unfortunately, Tim Armstrong’s voice doesn’t lend itself to this style. What you end up with is a lost puppy of a song, whimpering along for more than four minutes. Finding out this song is that long is like when Homer Simpson’s brother Herb finds out that the car Homer designed costs $82,000.
“L.A. River” has the same melody as “This Party Sucks” by The Slickee Boys. I guess the band is too loud. “Lulu” doesn’t really sound like Rancid, either, but it’s a fun little ditty.
Sometimes Rancid pretends to be a ska band, and generally it works fine. “Liberty and Freedom” follows in this tradition. I could listen to this song all day.
Really we should just be happy that Rancid is creating anything new at all.